Dodgeball was definitely another of my most interested in campaigns. Knowing it's a magic inside non magic makes it a close second to magic school. I've just seen/read so much media involved.with magic schools that I'm pulling for that haha! Renaissance time would be a cool setting as well.

Dodgeball is 100% a "magical world inside normal world" campaign, like legitimately leaning into the concept more than most TBH.  Certainly way more than anything I've ran with this group.

The magical school concept has not been explored nearly as much but there's a lot of room for it.  It also makes it super easy to have a scripted reason why you all are at the same spot.
In the Renaissance/FutureRandWorld campaign, it would be the Black Tower or White Tower depending on whether it was male or female students. 
I did not specifically have a magical school written into the fantasy campaign, but even just sitting here thinking about it I can picture exactly where on the map it would be lol.  New canon!!

Food: I'm good with whatever interrupts the game the least. Even if thats getting food myself after the session.

Beyond that, most of the nitty-gritty is already in this thread (esp the 12/17 post) or was similar to what we've discussed over chicken wings.  The only major caveat being order of importance.  And here I can give a perfect example:
FOOD - discussing and organizing what is going to work best for those, like you, who have to work a full shift on Wed will be my absolutely first priority when the torch passes my way.  I'm not going to attempt to DM over food preparation, discussion, or ingestion.  Deciding how folks want to handle food is more important than which campaign we choose.

At this point in time id like to know the "Big" questions of what to think on and come with an opinion.

I'm currently veering towards the idea of a group-build-world.  Longform pregame.

This is still where I'm at as far as games on the docket.  4 campaigns that could be good to go on the fly.

Robbie, I'm not sure your goal in terms of playing "other games" instead.  I'm not opposed to the idea, but generally attendance/interest is much lower when we do alt-days.  If I know your motivation I might be able to come up with a more appropriate response?

1 is low 9 is high

Some examples:  "I've wanted more or less of ...."

Combat :: Conversation
Exploration :: Stockpiling
Humor :: Seriousness
InGameDowntime :: EpicTimeLimits
HighMagic :: NoMagic
StoneAge :: SpaceTech
HumanOnly :: aliens&mutants
etc

Here was a fun list of campaign types i found on reddit.  i want to say we've done a majority of them to some degree (although a % of these were on OG Monday games not Wed).  Glad we got to finally cross the "Sci-Fi Fantasy Space Opera" off the list after space!!! ROFL

High fantasy hero quest

Low fantasy knight quest

Dark fantasy survival quest

Hack-n-slash dungeon crawl

Surviving a hostile natural environment

Post-apocalypse survival

Big heist

Political intrigue

War campaign

High seas era treasure hunt

Superheroes

Sci-Fi Fantasy Space Opera

Monster hunters

Attending a magic school

Secret magical world in modern day

I'm currently veering towards the idea of a group-build-world.  Longform pregame.

Current or Available

Unnamed Island
 Robbie's current Wed

Space.. TOO!!
 open-world campaign available for one-shots at player request.  Quests varied to include a variety of RPG styles to suit the requesting group.

Sleep Project
  available horror/comedy one-shot

Active Development

Dodgeball 
 this one would most easily play out like a Beyond the Supernatural or White Wolf Hunter campaign.  The PCs would be members of a professional dodgeball team, unexpectedly pulled into the hidden world of the monstrous.  Winning the ADAA is clutch, but so is checking out the supernatural and maintaining the mask.  Dodge (+Av cap Perc), Duck (stance +Av -speed), Dip (ready action to Catch), Dive (standard action stacking +Av/San), AndDodge! (stacking +Av half-ranks).
 time period could vary.  anything from anachronistically inconsistent archer-style, to cyber-punk almost-rifts (no lasers or particle beams yet, but other standard rifts tech is the current cutting edge)

Fantasy Tweaked
 originally designed as a Dark Sun world (although likely in a heavily reimagined format focusing on the flavor, not the specifics).  total new map, limited races of which folks must be one, would present a very good chance for group world building.  magic might work weird, not wild, but more caveats than normal.  additional dimensional aspects.  at this point i've leaned less into that aspect of dark sun, but it could add a new flavor to the gumbo almost at the level of the hivemind.  optional variant only.
 long story short i can spit out fully functional fantasy worlds with full geological and anthropological roots pretty fast these days.  these can lean a lot of ways in terms of type of campaign, since the map is just the canvas.

Rennaissance
  would stand out the most for being a Rennaissance time period rather than stone/middle ages. setting would be Randworld, leaning into events a couple hundred years after the utopia at the end of the WoT books.  not heavy on fanfic, just ease of having prebuilt real history for non-readers.  definite limits on the magic system but pretty straightforward ones, elemental caps and specializations, lots of counterspelling and disabling other casters.  could lean a lot of ways in terms of type of campaign.

Undeveloped

We Shrunk The PCs
 this one has come up several times recently in different context.  Undeveloped, the basic idea is fighting through the challenges of being an inch tall in your own backyard.  I envision this unfolding as a humorous dungeon crawl, and likely only lasting a short time period

"Mob" Suggestion
 a couple players insisted that this had come up a couple times, and so therefore added to the list